Netflix’s The Old Guard 2, released July 2, 2025, reunites Charlize Theron’s Andy with her immortal comrades, now facing new threats both external and internal. Joining the ensemble is Uma Thurman as Discord, the original immortal turned adversary, and Vân Veronica Ngô reprising Quỳnh, long believed dead. Despite its promise of global locations and adrenaline-fuelled set pieces, critics have largely panned the sequel for its technical shortcomings and narrative missteps.

Promising Premise, Flat Execution

Early in the film, an intense rescue introduces Quỳnh, who resurfaces seeking revenge after centuries of underwater imprisonment. Meanwhile, Andy grapples with her own mortality, a bold shift that could have deepened the emotional stakes. Yet critics describe the action sequences and character dynamics as underwhelming. While the setup is compelling, the sequel fails to delve into character psyches or deliver gripping action, leaving crucial subplots unexplored.

Technical and Creative Misfires

Reviewers have repeatedly flagged glaring technical flaws: poor lighting, echoey audio, and uninspired fight choreography. One critic described "terrible echoey sound" mixed with "rubbish fight choreography" and criticized the dialogue’s soap-opera tone in exotic backdrops from Italy to South Korea. Others noted diminished character relationships and frail action sequences under director Victoria Mahoney.

Cliffhanger That Feels Incomplete

Perhaps the most divisive element is the film’s abrupt ending. Mid-climax, the narrative halts, abandoning any full resolution and hinting at a continuation, though no sequel has been confirmed. Some reviewers lamented that the second movie "ends or, rather, stops mid‑climax" with no clear intent to resume, while others dismissed it as a "lifeless sequel" that leaves audiences frustrated rather than excited.

Silver Linings Amid the Disappointment

Despite its flaws, the sequel isn’t without merit. Some standout performances, especially from Matthias Schoenaerts, bring depth, and the emotional arc of a same‑sex couple adds a heartfelt layer. Uma Thurman delivers a compelling presence as Discord, and early action sequences, including a car chase and an arms dealer takedown, offer brief glimpses of the film's potential.

Rotten Tomato Trend and Fan Feedback

Despite critical disapproval, The Old Guard 2 has garnered audience attention. Rotten Tomatoes user scores vary, with reactions ranging from harsh to generous. Some viewers say, “You won’t be missing out on anything,” while others admire the film’s concept and cast. The reception is clearly divided, some feel they wasted their time, while others hold out hope for improvement in a third installment.

With an estimated two-star average, The Old Guard 2 falls short of its predecessor’s emotional engagement and slick direction. While the original was praised for its balance of action and heart, this sequel lacks narrative depth, technical polish, and a satisfying conclusion.

In its attempt to heighten stakes through themes of mortality and revenge, The Old Guard 2 ultimately stumbles. Unless Netflix greenlights a third chapter with major improvements, the franchise risks fading into irrelevance rather than achieving immortality.